Gracjan Labowicz, MSA

GSA Sustainability Prize 2022 shortlisted

The sustainability of design actions and reactions to climate change consequences were at the forefront of the final design thesis.

Glasgow’s city networks, economics, and industries will be severely damaged due to flooding as a direct consequence of global climate change shortly (2030). The inaction of governments pre-and-post-COP26 and blatant ignorance of climate change in public debate demand urgent activity and preparation for this new design environment and conditions in our cities globally. How do we tackle flooding? Megaprojects: a viable and reliable answer to flooding?

Case studies on existing city flood defense strategies have shown the costs, Co2 emission, duration of construction, and eventual failures of mega-projects as inadequate in the climate change timetable. These structures cannot be entirely relied on- they are lumps of fragile, breakable concrete. The counterforce: water; it is an incredibly complex and robust matter. Almost impossible to predict its behaviour. With so little time to plan, a focus and ideological shift are needed. Instead of working up an outdated Victorian mentality of keeping water away from cities, adopting ideas that welcome excess water into them and manage it through urban water reservoir projects, flooding squares, and re-naturation of the river bank and surrounds- part of sponge city ideology.

An immediate strategy is required. However, it has to be conducted across the city architecturally. It is designed as a public space or has a valuable function other than protecting against flooding. Examples of the involvement of natural and green flooding solutions illustrate the possibility of implementing those throughout the city through smaller-scale projects. A good mix of landscape design, flooding control, and various treatment to the city’s existing fabric offers a fantastic upgrade to the quality of spaces, protecting them from flood damage.

These proposals could be considered a contemporary way forward, abandoning exploration of considerable water barriers- opening an alternative window for solutions. They could positively transform city spaces into usable public spaces.
However, they would also increase the amount of green space and planting in the Green city of Glasgow- so key in the carbon-capturing process and minimization of rapid escalation of the climate change process. They offer flexibility and commitment- what if flooding will not occur- those smaller-scale proposals will remain relevant to the city and bring the general public closer to nature in the city realms.

Citywide small scale initiatives to manage flooding and green solutions must be managed. The site at Govan Dry Docks- a former shipbuilding industry site, is one of the most significant contributors to CO2 emissions. Between 1844 and 1963, Denny’s shipyard alone built over 1500 ships.

The suggested intervention on the abandoned property considers the environmental payback scenario. It’s a long-term catastrophe planning department and facilitator for nature-based city solutions. The intervention will involve public consultation on a new water security framework and flooding control. It simplifies citywide implementation.

Govan Dry Docks, the last standing, evocative, and most complete shipbuilding heritage site in Glasgow is predicted to be flooded entirely. It is a symbol of Glasgow’s development as an international city- now, it will take a role in saving its city by planning for floods and reversing climate change through carbon capture.

Cyan Society takes over Govan Dry Docks in a hypothetical scenario. This new secret society builds a massive floodwall around the site’s perimeter, foretelling a citywide flood. The city is prepared. It advocates for nature-based flood solutions instead of dams or storm barriers. As a protest, the city is greened to make a place and space for nature. The occupied site by the cyan society is used as a manufacturing chain, knowledge division and disaster planning division.

Scaffolding is a representation of the struggle of forces and urgent issues. It can be erected fast to respond to flooding. In situ building process of scaffolding tension structure against future floods maintains the idea that this project can be built by the community. It also symbolizes the amount of effort and systematic action that needs to be taken to battle climate change. In between walls, 50mm pre-treated poles are inserted to withstand flood stresses.

Woodsmanship.

On-site timber construction creates a durable flood wall. Pressure treatment repurposes and adapts recycled timber to be utilised in water, reinforcing its compatibility. Glass is the most prevalent window material, yet it’s expensive economically and environmentally. Manufacturing emits 25,000 tonnes each year. Study “Forest Products Laboratory (FPL) researcher Junyong Zhu produced a translucent wood substance that may be the window of tomorrow. Transparent wood could outperform glass in practically every way, according to researchers.” The thesis examines wood as a future only construction material. It shows that it can be used to make water- and fire-resistant products and flexible structural solutions. It’s renewable and eco-friendly.

Seaweed.

Seaweed is considered a natural material asset. It can be used as a material, but it is considered a tremendous natural carbon-capturing machine. It is harvested, collected and dried on the scaffolding tension structure and processed further inside the manufacturing chain, and used for the production of ethical insulation and other uses.

The vision of opportunity. The proposal dwells on a vision of opportunity. One relatively positive- where it explores a scenario where flooding is controlled promptly on the one hand, while the city benefits from architectural and landscape projects across the city and receives a lot more green spaces. The river becomes more occupied and attended, and Seaweed and wetlands create a natural carbon capture machine and material resource. This is a very optimistic outlook on the future- Flooding and climate implications are unexpected and unknown; therefore a progressive and adaptable response is more realistic. If the flood doesn’t happen, the flood defences are demountable and recyclable. Suppose master plan vision projects are carried out. In that case, they will improve vacant and dilapidated sites, therefore would only improve those areas by providing an extension of the natural environment in the city. This makes the approach and scheme a very palatable proposition in the context of the control flooding strategy for Glasgow.

Motivation. This work it’s vital to me as climate change consequences will be dealt with in my lifetime. As a designer, I would like to be prepared for that eventuality. I want to act now and research and implement any solution that will start the reversal process of climate change or its saving and re-naturation of my environment. I love cities and built environments, but my heart beats on point in forests- I would like to see more of them- I would like to see them in cities. This effort aims to raise awareness about how important the challenges are and how we should respond effectively and architecturally to this near-future worldwide issue. I wish to see more designers adapting to life in water, re-greening cities, and delivering good design solutions and life adaptations for those affected by future flooding disasters and climate change.

Section captions:
Manufacturing Chain. Using renewable materials (wood, seaweed) and their on-site adaptation back up an idea of a replacement industry. This new renewable green industry replaces the old carbon-producing shipbuilding industry. At the early stages of the project, the machinery for timber pressure treatment and workshops are housed in this location, actively taking part in the construction of the Noah’s Arc. Manufacturing chain takes an active role in the production of goods as part of the citywide strategy master plan.

Knowledge Division. Cyan Society focuses on adaptability and natural materials. Natural remedies require research, testing, and lab work. This space explores Seaweed, urban wetland applications, floods monitoring stations, and natural carbon capture. This space is also productive. Scaffolding planters grow plants. Clean air filtered by plants is a great characteristic of the surrounding pavilions and ample space. The room also houses and exhibits antiquities from flood-prone locations, such as transport museum artefacts. Special “wood” glass cases safeguard and display acid-damaged Riverside Museum or Duke of Wellington statue collections. Botanic Gardens’ Black Oak and Japanese Alder grow there. Noah’s Arc stores priceless goods at risk of flood destruction or other climate disasters.

Disaster Planning Division. The disaster planning division consists of spaces for public and cyan society use. Public members are invited to take hands-on action on neighbourhood planning for affected areas in the city by flooding. Interior space features one closed set of collaborative working office spaces & several temporary pavilions housing closed office spaces for architects and planners. The public engages with the space through the central walkway to meander between different issues debated in the disaster planning division. Central space features a debating & presentation chamber.

More on our Tumblr feed